Sunday, February 5, 2012

Comment on the “Psychoneurotics” from Three Essays on Sexuality


Out of three essays from Sigmund Freud’s Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality, I thought the fact that “psyneuroses are based on sexual instinctual forces” was particularly interesting. Psychoneurotics are sufferers from hysteria, from obsessional neurosis, from what is wrongly described as neurasthenia, and from dementia praecox and paranoia. According to Freud, neurosis reveals the question of the sexual life of the persons. In addition, the symptoms constitute the sexual activity of the patient. This was interesting to me because I have never expected that metal disorders would closely be linked to sexual instincts or desires. However, at the same time, I am not very sure if neurosis can entirely be explained from the sexual analysis since many other external factors may contribute to mental problems such as hysteria and paranoia. For example, bad relationship of parents highly influences the child’s personality which, in extreme case, causes the child to develop obsession or paranoia for a certain thing.

           Freud also argues that “the character of hysterics shows a degree of sexual repression in excess of the normal quantity, an intensification of resistance against the sexual instinct, and what seems like an instinctive aversion o their part to any intellectual consideration of sexual problems.” And as a result of this, the patients remain in complete ignorance of sexual matters right into the period of the sexual maturity. I thought this argument made sense as when I thought about constantly repressing certain desire and keeping it inside, I would eventually feel suffocating and have mental confusion by myself which could lead to hysteria. I am not very sure if that desire only applies to normal sexual instinct, but I did find his claim – all neurotics show impulses for sexual life or instinct but in a passive form – very interesting.

No comments:

Post a Comment